Evidence
Where prop firms contradict themselves
6 open points at 3 firms where the firm’s own pages state two different things, and 12 since closed. Both statements, with sources.
- 6open points
- 3firms with an open point
- 12closed after a second read
Open
DayTraders.comAffects money
Profit split
The homepage states "Keep 100% of profits" (read 17 Nov 2026). The firm's help article on Live payouts states an 80/20 split (read 16 Nov 2026). Treat 100% as applying to Pro and S2F accounts only.
Both read 17 Nov 2026 · first logged 10 Sep 2026
Elite Trader FundingAffects money
Sim payout cap
- What we publish
- Help centre, LIVE ELITE article: a $25,000 payout cap per trader, after which the trader moves to LIVE ELITE Source: help.elitetraderfunding.com
- Conflicting statement
- Homepage: "keep up to 100% of $150,000 in lifetime SIM-funded profit" Source: elitetraderfunding.app
The homepage states up to 100% of $150,000 in lifetime sim-funded profit (read 17 Nov 2026). The firm's help centre names a $25,000 payout cap per trader (read 16 Nov 2026). We record $25,000, the more specific statement.
Both read 17 Nov 2026 · first logged 10 Sep 2026
Elite Trader FundingAffects the rules
1 step account sizes
- What we publish
- /evaluations price list: 50K, 100K and 150K, each with a price Source: elitetraderfunding.app
The 1 Step plan page names 50K, 100K and 250K in its intro. The price list on the evaluations page prices 50K, 100K and 150K. Both read 17 Nov 2026. We list the sizes that carry a price: 50K, 100K and 150K.
Both read 17 Nov 2026 · first logged 10 Sep 2026
IQ CapitalAffects the rules
Rapid free retries
- What we publish
- Checkout: a Rapid evaluation reset costs $134 on the 50K futures account Source: checkout.iqcapital.io
- Conflicting statement
- "Free activation and free retries" in the Rapid description on /pricing Source: iqcapital.io
Checked 17 Nov 2026, still open. Activation is free. A reset is not.
Both read 17 Nov 2026 · first logged 22 Sep 2026
IQ CapitalAffects the rules
Rapid payout cadence
- What we publish
- Rapid 1D pays after 1 active trading day, Rapid 3D after 3 per cycle (help centre article on Rapid rewards, checkout). /general-rules states 0 minimum days in the challenge Source: support.iqcapital.io
- Conflicting statement
- Help centre article "Required Minimum Trading Days" (23 Sep 2026): Rapid needs 3 minimum trading days in the challenge and pays after 3 active trading days Source: support.iqcapital.io
Checked 17 Nov 2026, still open. We publish the 1D and 3D cadence from checkout. The 3 day challenge minimum stays unconfirmed.
Both read 17 Nov 2026 · first logged 22 Sep 2026
IQ CapitalMinor
Max accounts crypto 200k
- What we publish
- Checkout fee tab: Total Funded Accounts 5 on the 200K CFD and crypto Core challenge Source: checkout.iqcapital.io
Checked 17 Nov 2026, still open. We publish 5, the limit shown at purchase.
Both read 17 Nov 2026 · first logged 22 Sep 2026
Closed
IQ Capital · Jurisdiction
Closed 17 Nov 2026. The imprint and the footer name the Saint Lucia company. The earlier FAQ line about a UAE incorporation is gone.
Confirmed 17 Nov 2026
IQ Capital · Profit split core
Closed 17 Nov 2026: the pricing page no longer carries the "first $10,000 are 100% yours, then 80:20" line, and the futures and crypto pages now state "Up to 90% profit split". No IQ Capital page read today contradicts the 90/10 split on Core.
Confirmed 17 Nov 2026
IQ Capital · Profit split rapid
Closed 17 Nov 2026: the payout page now reads "No threshold, no tiers ... You keep up to 90% of your profit". "Up to 90%" no longer contradicts the 80/20 split on Rapid accounts.
Confirmed 17 Nov 2026
IQ Capital · Rapid loss limits
Closed 17 Nov 2026. The tagline that contradicted the account details was removed. The daily loss limit applies to the funded 1D plan only.
Confirmed 17 Nov 2026
Earn2Trade · Min trading days
Closed 17 Nov 2026: the Trader Career Path page states "No Minimum Trading Days" six times and no longer carries any "Minimum 10 Trading Days" text, visible or collapsed.
Confirmed 17 Nov 2026
FTMO · Currency
Closed 17 Nov 2026: this is a display note about currencies, not two FTMO pages stating different terms. We publish the euro list price and label the currency.
Confirmed 17 Nov 2026
Funded Futures Network · Activation fee
Closed 17 Nov 2026: the homepage states "No activation fee after passing" and the FAQ answer to "What fees do I pay once I pass the evaluation?" names only market data fees on Institution accounts. Both read the same day. We record no activation fee.
Confirmed 17 Nov 2026
IQ Capital · Monthly fee futures
Closed 17 Nov 2026. Checkout, pricing page and rules page now agree: no monthly fee on futures challenges.
Confirmed 17 Nov 2026
IQ Capital · Price crypto core
Closed 17 Nov 2026. List prices match. The pricing page rounds the discounted price to the dollar.
Confirmed 17 Nov 2026
Tradeify · Payout denials
Closed 17 Nov 2026: tradeify.co read in full, the claim "0% Payout Denials" is no longer on the homepage (it now states "$400M+ Verified Payouts"). The other side was a Trustpilot review, not a Tradeify page.
Confirmed 17 Nov 2026
Elite Trader Funding · End of day account sizes
Closed 17 Nov 2026: the End of Day plan page lists two sizes (50K, 100K) and the price list on the evaluations page prices the same two. Both read the same day.
Confirmed 17 Nov 2026
IQ Capital · Max drawdown futures core
Closed 17 Nov 2026. The 6% and 5% on the rules page equal the Max Position Loss version at checkout. The Daily Loss Limit version runs a tighter $2,000 and $3,000 drawdown, which the rules page does not spell out.
Confirmed 17 Nov 2026
How this ledger works
- Every entry compares two statements by the same firm. We read both on the day shown and quote or summarise each.
- An entry is listed only after both places were read on the same check. Nothing here comes from a review site or a forum.
- The order is open points first, then by what the point touches: money, rules, minor. It is not a ranking of firms.
Questions
- What counts as a contradiction here?
- Two statements from the same firm that cannot both be true: a pricing page against the checkout, a rules page against a help article, a homepage claim against the payout terms. A difference between a firm and a review site does not count.
- Which figure does PropTraderCheck publish when a firm contradicts itself?
- The one closest to the purchase and the payout: the checkout before a pricing page, the terms and help articles before a homepage line. Each entry names the statement we publish and the one that conflicts with it.
- When does a point close?
- When we read both places again and they agree, or the conflicting statement is gone. Closed points stay on the page with the day we confirmed it.
- What should a trader do with an open point?
- Ask the firm in writing before buying, and keep the reply. In a payout dispute the firm will rely on its terms, not on its marketing.